Port Elizabeth of Yore : Volume 1 – Defying the Odds – Now Available

This volume is now available as follows: Soft cover = R 250, hard cover R475 plus shipment costs to SA destinations at R100. Copies of the book can be collected in Joburg from Dean [082 801 5446], Cape Town from Blaine [074 103 7137] and at Port Elizabeth from Alan [084 981 8491 oe 041 368 1304]. Alternatively email Dean at deanm@orangedotdesigns.co.za.

Banking details:

Bank: Standard Bank Branch: Clearwater Mall Account number: 00 294 451 0 Swift code for overseas payments: SBZAZAJJ Reference: Will be provided before EFT is performed

As Port Elizabeth celebrated its bicentenary in April 2020, this event has to be celebrated for not only was it the birth of a new town, but it was also home to many of our ancestors. This four-volume set of books records those birth pangs and well as the people and events which over the next 150 years made Port Elizabeth what it is today.

Comments on the back cover

Initially Port Elizabeth was only earmarked as a landing place for the British settlers and not as their destination. Yet in the thirty-year period from 1820 to 1850, contrary to expectations it experienced a tremendous growth spurt. So prodigious in fact was its expansion that it even overtook Cape Town in terms of the volume of exports.

This is the story of the people and events that form the basis of this incredible journey.

This book forms part of a four-volume series which takes the reader on the fascinating odyssey from the original inhabitants – the Khoi – through the town’s development into an entrepôt, wool processor and exporter to its pinnacle as the Detroit of South Africa.

Port Elizabeth of Yore: Depictions of a Struggling Town in 1830

One can safely assume that prior to the establishment of the first newspaper, the E.P. Herald, in Port Elizabeth in 1845, and before the establishment of Port Elizabeth as a borough in July 1860, very little historical information was formally recorded. In their endeavours to earn a living in a town without facilities, recording history took a low priority in their lives. Until that time, it was visitors and travellers who recorded their observations of the town. Most of them were not complimentary about it but that is the only source of information of this nascent town.

In this blog, it is the journal maintained by the Assistant Surgeon on the ship, the Falcon, which forms the basis of William Dunn’s observations of the town. They are trenchant and incisive, unflattering in their candour but were no different from those of many an observer from that period.

Main picture: Port Elizabeth in February 1835 painted by Charles Michell. The Inn at which Gunn and his fellow mariners shared breakfast is the large building on the hill

Biographical detail  

Dunn’s journal provides little in the way of information about himself except at one point he does mention that he was turning twenty-five. This must mean that he was born in 1804. William Gunn, who was appointed     to the Falcon in June 1828 and to the Pelorus in October 1831, was the Assistant Surgeon on both ships.

On arrival in the Cape Colony, much of his· time was spent at Wynberg in the company of ” Indian Officers” i.e., members of the East India Company’s service on furlough at the Cape. He was also befriended by Mackay, the collector of customs, at whose home he met Dr. (later Sir) Andrew Smith, the naturalist and explorer and founder of the South African Museum.

His activities whilst in Cape Town have been ignored as it is his description of Port Elizabeth which is of principal interest.

Voyage to the East

The Falcon sailed for Port Elizabeth on Wednesday 20th January 1830, arriving there four days later. According to Professor F.G. Richings who was introduced to this diary by the curator of the Killie Campbell Africana Collection in Berea Durban, “The purpose of the voyage appears to have been to convey ”treasure” destined for Grahamstown – probably as payment of the garrison’s wages and other expenses connected with the Frontier Administration. In his journal, Gunn mentions ”the treasure” of £ 10,000 being taken on board a few hours before the ship sailed.

Sunday 24th January

Gunn notes in his diary: “Since we sailed from Simon’s Bay, we have had the most pleasant weather, so mild that we carried Royals all the time with the wind from the southward and westward. Saw Cape Recife ahead this morning at day light. Ran along in sight of the shore all the time. The coast in some parts is bold and mountainous, in others low, especially as we approached Cape Recife, which forms the western extremity of Algoa Bay. The breeze, which was light in the morning, freshened as we approached Recife, and when we entered the Bay, we had a beautiful stiff breeze. We anchored at 2 p.m.

Port Elizabeth is a very poor little place, surrounded partly by sand and partly by brush wood and barren waste, interspersed here and there with small spots which bear marks of cultivation.  The houses, which are not numerous, are built without regularity and separated from each other. Many of the houses are built after the Dutch custom, whitewashed outside with thatched roofs, but others are built with bricks and covered with tiles which are both made here and exactly similar to those of English make.

By all accounts Port Elizabeth was a miserable place with the southeaster sprinkling the hamlet with sand. Even though the Deputy Governor had in June 1820 authorised surveyor James Swan to prepare a plan of the lots available to those wishing to set­tle here, many houses no better than shacks had already been erected. Exacerbating this was the fact that the houses were scattered higgledy-piggledy over these plots. The survivors of the wreck of the Zeepaard were also to be struck by this disorderly layout.

The Diary on the 24th continues: “An officer with a detachment of the 55th Regt. is stationed here which is, I suppose, rather dull work for him.  Saw a vessel on shore wrecked and was told that it was the Francis Watson, store ship, which sailed from Simons Bay lately. She went on shore on Wednesday night 13th January in a gale from the South East.  This is a very unsafe place to lay with a strong wind from the S.E., for you are very much exposed.”

Monday 25th January.

Went on shore early this morning with Hope, Williams and young Harris of the Maidstone. Met the Captain on landing.

Got some mess things. Purchased a quantity of butter which is found very cheap and good here (at 9d per lb.) for our own Mess and that of “Maidstone’s” larboard berth.  Breakfasted at the Inn which appears a comfortable house, a very large house for the size of the place.  It is very cheap, for our breakfast which was very substantial (consisting of cold fowl, lamb, mutton, mutton chops, eggs, tea etc.) only cost us one shilling each. This Inn is kept by an Englishman.

This Inn could not have been the Red Lion in High [Main] Street as in 1823 Hitge had sold it to the colonial authorities for use as a Customs Office. In all probability it was the Markham Hotel which was originally built as accommodation for Captain Moresby. Being in the Royal Navy, he was never to take occupation. It subsequently became the Markham Hotel and later Scorey’s Hotel.

The English language is spoken more generally here than in any other part of the colony. There are a great many English settlers about this place and, I believe, all along the frontier of this colony.  There is an obelisk erected above the town on the hill by Sir Rufane Donkin to the memory (of) his wife who died at sea in (sic) her way from India to this colony.  The following is part of the inscription on this column:

” In the memory of one of the most amiable of her sex and that most perfect of human beings who gave her name to the town below. She died leaving – children and a husband behind who will ever deplore the irreparable loss he has sustained.”

Lady Donkin’s name was Elizabeth, and this place was named Port Elizabeth after her.

Gunn’s account of the inscription on the Donkin Memorial is, of course, erroneous: it was probably written from memory once he was back on board. What Gunn fails to mention is on the 28th May 1825, English was declared the official language for judicial transactions.

The surf was running high on the beach so that we were obliged to get from the shore in a surf boat which are much required here, for it is seldom that any other boat is enabled to land with safety at Port Elizabeth. There is a warp fixed to the shore and also to an anchor which is a considerable way outside the surf where other boats lay until they receive or discharge their cargoes into the Surf boats which are built with flat bottoms which are continued flat towards each end forming angles so

This place is about 120 miles from Graham’s Town.  Mr. Hunt Rl.  Marines starts (for) that place tomorrow in the wagon which carries the treasure there. The oxen which I saw in their wagons are much larger and finer than those about Cape Town.  I cannot judge of the goodness of their horses as I only saw a few ponies.

Came on board this forenoon. Dined with the Captain as also did the Master and young Harris.  Got under way about five o’ clock and stood out of Algoa Bay with a light, but foul breeze . . .

According to Richings. “By all accounts, Gunn was not overly impressed by what he saw but then, few visitors of the period were. When he arrived in Algoa Bay for the second time in August the same year, he noted laconically ‘Port Elizabeth looking as miserable as ever!’ Clearly, the years of growth were still far ahead.

Like all such accounts of visitors of this period, Gunn’s description of the town is brief. Nonetheless it is extremely valuable as being one of the few eyewitness accounts of Port Elizabeth during its formative years and moreover it contains interesting information on disparate aspects such as layout, prices, the construction of its houses and the lingua franca.


A Naval Officer’s View of Port Elizabeth, 1830 by Professor F.G. Richings (Looking Back, December 1978, Volume 18, Number 4)

Port Elizabeth of Yore: The Destruction of the Architectural Integrity of the Market Square Precinct

Many people once pejoratively called Prince Charles a sentimental old fool for deploring the destruction of the architectural coherence of an area by demolishing an old building within a section of a town or street which epitomised a particular architectural style. As such, Charles was roundly condemned for wanting to stifle progress and advancement. Instead, it was an earnest plea by Charles to preserve such sections of the town where there was merit to do so. For not to exercise caution would destroy the architectural integrity of that area.

Sadly, Port Elizabeth has witnessed the destruction of such an area which would fall within the remit of Charles’ rebuke. Without a doubt, this area encompasses the old Market Square and includes Jetty Street and the old Customs House. To this we can add the demolition of the Fleming building and the old Collegiate School for use as a parking area

Main picture: The Main Library in 1939. All of these buildings whether they were constructed in 1859 like the Grey Institute or the Donkin lighthouse in 1861 are still standing. At this date if one had to turn around and look across Market Square, all of the original buildings would still be standing. From Castle Corner to the Mosenthal and Richardson buildings, they would all be present. Then as in in fit of pique, in the 1970s they would all be demolished.

Continue reading

Port Elizabeth of Yore: On the Cusp of the 20th Century

This blog is loosely based upon the reminiscences of Mrs. Margery Lochhead who was born in 1888 in Port Elizabeth and recalls the town of her youth. Not only was the town on the cusp of a new century but it would also herald the advent of revolutionary technologies such as the motor vehicle and electricity. These inventions would forever change the mode of transport but also humanity’s relationships with work and leisure.

However, these changes were still in the future. In the latter part of the 19th century, the horse, the cart and Shank’s Pony [i.e. one’s own legs] were still the predominant modes of travel.

Main picture: Main Street before 1883. Note that this portion of western Main Street north of Donkin Street still possessed numerous of the original basic single and double storey buildings. As redevelopment steadily extended towards Russell Street, in due course these buildings would be replaced with larger more elegant structures

Continue reading

Port Elizabeth of Yore: The First Jetty

When the elements defeat ingenuity and determination

The first practical scheme to improve Port Elizabeth’s harbour facilities was mooted barely ten years after the arrival of the 1820 Settlers. This reflects the stunning growth of Port Elizabeth as a harbour. Notwithstanding the determination of the local residents, politics and other considerations would intrude to prevent the hopes and aspirations of this dream being realised.

Nine years after being mooted in 1831, construction of the First Jetty commenced in 1840. The maxim, “The past we inherit and the future we create,” was now validated. This blog covers the cycle of this project from its initial conceptualisation to its unfortunate, untimely and unexpected destruction in 1843.

Main picture: The first jetty

Continue reading

Alex of Yore: Paul Ellis with Poetry in his Veins

The one thing that I recall about Paul is his endeavour to make us understand poetry by writing some ourselves. In attempting to do so, I soon realised writing poetry was more difficult than one anticipated.

Every biography is different. For me the most satisfying have been the one-on-one interviews such as with Flippie as they provide an insight into the real person. In most cases, the best that was possible was an interview with a surviving spouse such as Fay Welsh or the children of Cordingley. Paul’s was completely different in that I was given a typed biography. Even without a verbal interview, one aspect of the man shines through and that is his humanity and a gentle spirit.

This is the autobiography of Paul Ellis.

Main picture: Farewell from Muir  in December 1992

Continue reading

Lost Artefacts of Port Elizabeth: The Mosenthal’s Building in Market Square

The demolition of this elegant and stately building was a loss in two aspects. Firstly in and of itself, due to its architectural merits, the building deserved to be retained. More importantly this building together with the other buildings in Market Square represented an integrated whole. The demolition of an elegant late Victorian building and replacing it with a faux modern prison-like building was unconscionable and unforgiveable. The whole area deserved to be retained as a whole

Main picture: Mosenthal’s building in Market Square

Continue reading

Port Elizabeth of Yore: Uitenhage enters the Industrial Age

By 1806, two years after the town of Uitenhage was founded, the districts of Uitenhage and Graaff Reinet possessed 72.9% of the sheep in South Africa. With only 19.2% of the Cape’s population, and 60.4 head of sheep per person in these districts, one has two wonder why this anomaly arose. It would take another 20 years after the establishment of Port Elizabeth in 1820 before the export of wool would make sheep breeding a profitable undertaking. It is these exports which would provide the impetus for the creation of wool processing industries in both Uitenhage and Port Elizabeth.

Main picture: Springfield – One of the first woolwasheries in Uitenhage

Continue reading

(Judge) Hlophe: Abandon All Hope Ye (White Men) Who Enter Here

(Judge) Hlophe should have been dealt with long ago – fired, impeached or whatever they do to hack judges.  His defence for his prior contraventions seems to have been a he said / she said situation or a misinterpretation of what he actually stated.  However, his latest outrage is blatant and not subject to misinterpretation.  Furthermore, it is wilful in that it displays a conscious disregard for facts known by him in order to express a personal opinion and advance a biased racist narrative.  As such, he is not a fit and proper person to be a judge, not only for white people appearing before him, but everyone because he has displayed a creative relationship with facts (evidence) before him.  A Trumpian personality of the first water.

Continue reading